By Alan Hazlett

The price of precise trust has performed a crucial function in background of philosophy—consider Socrates’ slogan that the unexamined existence isn't worthy dwelling, and Aristotle’s declare that everybody evidently wishes knowledge—as good as in modern epistemology, the place questions on the price of data have lately taken middle degree. It has frequently been assumed that actual representation—true belief—is worthy, both instrumentally or for its personal sake. In A luxurious of the Understanding, Allan Hazlett bargains a serious research of that assumption, and of the most ways that it may be defended.


Hazlett defends the realization that precise trust is at such a lot occasionally precious. within the first a part of the ebook, he pursuits the view that actual trust is generally larger for us than fake trust, and argues that fake ideals approximately ourselves—for instance, unrealistic optimism approximately our futures and approximately other folks, similar to overly confident perspectives of our friends—are frequently beneficial vis-a-vis our wellness. within the moment half, he goals the view that fact is “the goal of belief,” and argues for anti-realism concerning the epistemic price of real trust. jointly, those arguments include a problem to the philosophical assumption of the price of precise trust, and recommend an alternate photo, on which the truth that a few humans love fact is all there's to “the worth of precise belief.”

Show description

Read Online or Download A Luxury of the Understanding: On the Value of True Belief PDF

Best epistemology books

The Vital Roots of European Enlightenment: Ibn Tufayl's Influence on Modern Western Thought

The very important Roots of eu Enlightenment is a suite of essays which care for the effect of Ibn Tufayl, a 12th-century Arab thinker from Spain, on significant eu thinkers. His philosophical novel, Hayy Ibn Yaqzan, will be one among an important books that heralded the medical Revolution.

Apprehension: Reason in the Absence of Rules (Ashgate Epistemology & Mind)

This paintings introduces and explores the function of apprehension in reasoning - taking off the issues, identifying the vocabulary, solving the limits and wondering what's usually taken without any consideration. Lynn Holt argues powerful notion of rationality needs to comprise highbrow virtues which can't be diminished to a suite of ideas for reasoners, and argues that the advantage of apprehension, an received disposition to work out issues appropriately, is needed if rationality is to be defensible.

The Search after Truth: With Elucidations of The Search after Truth

Malebranche is now well-known as a tremendous determine within the heritage of philosophy, occupying a very important position within the Rationalist culture of Descartes, Spinoza and Leibniz. the hunt after fact is his first, longest and most crucial paintings; this quantity additionally provides the Elucidations that followed its 3rd version, the results of reviews that Malebranche solicited at the unique paintings and an immense repository of his theories of principles and causation.

Peirce’s Theory of Abduction

This monograph makes an attempt to elucidate one major yet a lot overlooked point of Peirce's contribution to the philosophy of technological know-how. It was once written in 1963 as my M. A. thesis on the Uni­ versity of Illinois. because the subject continues to be ignored it truly is was hoping that its e-book could be of use to Peirce students.

Additional info for A Luxury of the Understanding: On the Value of True Belief

Sample text

Moore’s rejection of the “naturalistic fallacy” (Principia Ethica, §§27–35). O. Quine and David Lewis, in the 20th century. For our purposes here, we can simply note the anthropological and metaphysical commitments that anyone takes on who wishes to defend a prescriptive version of the principle of curiosity on essentialist grounds. Below (Chapter 7) we’ll consider versions of Aristotelian functionalism based on the theory of evolution by natural selection. These views are empirically supported, scientifically credible inheritors of Aristotelian functionalism.

19 We can identify an important division among theories of wellbeing by considering their attitude towards the connection between a person’s wellbeing and her desires (broadly understood). 20 They make no essential reference to individual desires (broadly understood) in their account of individual wellbeing. Consider Parfit’s sketch of such a theory: The good things might include moral goodness, rational activity, the development of one’s abilities, having children and being a good parent, knowledge, and the awareness of true beauty.

You might think that the plausibility of the eudaimonic ideal of knowledge (and of the eudaimonic value of knowledge more generally) depends on the plausibility of the eudaimonic ideal of true belief (or at least on the eudaimonic value of true belief more generally). If the eudaimonic ideal of true belief isn’t defensible, then it’s hard to see how the eudaimonic ideal of knowledge could be defensible. In this sense, the eudaimonic ideal of true belief seems weaker, a less controversial and risky claim, than the eudaimonic ideal of knowledge (although cf.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.28 of 5 – based on 38 votes